Evolution’s missing CK hearing fuels talk of a possible settlement

Evolution's missing CK hearing fuels talk of a possible settlement

Evolution's missing UPEPA hearing: Did CK become a problem worth settling?

Monday's scheduled arguments between Evolution and Calcagni & Kanefsky never took place. With no public explanation available, the possibility of a private settlement deserves attention, particularly considering who the lawyers at CK are.

Something rather strange happened in New Jersey on Monday, 16 November. An entire day had reportedly been allocated to UPEPA arguments involving Evolution and the law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky (CK), one of the original defendants in Evolution's nearly five-year-old defamation lawsuit. Yet the expected hearing was never held, leaving people attempting to follow the proceedings through the court's livestream system wondering what had happened.

There has been no public explanation for the missing session, at least not one available to Malta Media by early Tuesday morning. I suspect most people would initially blame the usual courtroom scheduling complications, but I find the possibility of a settlement considerably more interesting. Especially when considering CK's role in the original Black Cube investigation and the professional backgrounds of the lawyers involved.

CK is not just another law firm

Thomas Calcagni, one of CK's founding partners, spent nine years as a federal prosecutor before serving as New Jersey's First Assistant Attorney General. That made him the second highest ranking prosecutor in the state, overseeing major criminal and civil investigations. His fellow founding partner, Eric Kanefsky, also worked as a federal prosecutor and subsequently headed New Jersey's Division of Consumer Affairs.

These are not lawyers unfamiliar with regulatory investigations or the consequences of submitting allegations to government authorities. CK was retained in connection with the Black Cube investigation and subsequently submitted its findings to gambling regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Evolution maintains that the report contained false allegations and that CK's involvement contributed to the damage allegedly caused to its business.

CK's position, as described in the dispute, is that it reviewed the investigative material and considered the submission to regulators appropriate. The legal significance of that position is considerable, particularly in proceedings concerning legislation intended to protect certain communications involving matters of public concern and government authorities.

I would imagine that Evolution's lawyers have considered what it might look like to have experienced former prosecutors defending their decision to bring suspected regulatory problems to the attention of gambling authorities. That would not establish the accuracy of every allegation in Black Cube's report, but it could make CK's position rather more difficult to attack than Evolution might have anticipated.

Perhaps Evolution decided Monday was a battle it did not need?

The possibility that Evolution has reached some arrangement with CK is speculation and I have no confirmation of a settlement. Nevertheless, the timing deserves more than just a little attention. Evolution has had almost five years to resolve this dispute, yet the anticipated hearing disappears immediately before CK was expected to present its arguments.

One possible explanation is that Evolution reconsidered its chances of defeating CK's UPEPA application. A successful dismissal could have consequences beyond simply losing claims against the law firm, potentially including liability for legal fees under the applicable legislation. It might also produce an uncomfortable judicial assessment of CK's decision to approach regulators.

Previous court rulings have given Evolution grounds for confidence in parts of its case, so there is no justification for assuming CK would necessarily win. But the reputations of the lawyers involved, their backgrounds in government enforcement and the circumstances in which the report was submitted could all become significant when the court examines the relevant claims.

A negotiated resolution might therefore make commercial sense. It could avoid further legal costs and remove one particularly awkward confrontation from the proceedings without requiring either party to admit wrongdoing. Evolution might also prefer to concentrate its efforts on Black Cube rather than continue fighting every defendant simultaneously.

There remains the possibility that Monday's proceedings were postponed or dealt with through some other procedural arrangement. That would be a considerably less exciting explanation, although the absence of any public clarification has hardly helped matters.

Black Cube hearing still going ahead?

Black Cube's UPEPA arguments are expected to proceed on Tuesday, 17 November, before Judge John C. Porto. Williams & Connolly, representing Black Cube, is expected to present arguments concerning the investigation and potentially some of the evidence gathered during it. An agreement involving CK, if one exists, would not automatically resolve Evolution's separate claims against Black Cube. Nor would it establish that Evolution has abandoned its wider litigation strategy, including its ambition to bring Playtech into the proceedings.

BUT, I find the possibility of Evolution quietly resolving part of the lawsuit rather intriguing. The company has spent years insisting that those involved in the original investigation should be held accountable. An unexplained change affecting one of the original defendants, immediately before an important hearing, deserves rather more attention than it has received so far.

Evolution and CK could clear up much of the uncertainty by confirming whether Monday's arguments were withdrawn, postponed or made unnecessary by an agreement between the parties. Until then, a private settlement remains one plausible explanation rather than an established development.

I have argued before that Evolution might eventually find it considerably cheaper to settle this dispute than continue fighting through years of litigation and potentially extensive discovery. If the company has started making that calculation with CK, it could be a sensible decision.

Considering the legal and commercial risks still facing Evolution, I would be surprised if somebody had not already put the numbers on the table.

FAQs

Why did Evolution's scheduled UPEPA hearing not take place?
The scheduled hearing involving Evolution and Calcagni & Kanefsky did not take place on 16 November 2026. No public explanation had been confirmed when the article was written.

Has Evolution reached a settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky?
There is no confirmed settlement between Evolution and Calcagni & Kanefsky. A private agreement remains one possible explanation for the missing hearing, but it is speculative.

What is Calcagni & Kanefsky's role in the Evolution lawsuit?
Calcagni & Kanefsky was involved in reviewing investigative material connected to Black Cube and submitting findings to gambling regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

What is UPEPA and why is it relevant to Evolution's lawsuit?
The Uniform Public Expression Protection Act provides procedures for seeking early dismissal of certain lawsuits involving protected communications, including communications with government authorities.

Who are Thomas Calcagni and Eric Kanefsky?
Thomas Calcagni and Eric Kanefsky are founding partners of CK with extensive backgrounds in federal prosecution, government enforcement and regulatory investigations.

What allegations does Evolution make against Black Cube?
Evolution alleges that the Black Cube investigation produced false and damaging claims about its business. The company has pursued legal action against parties connected to the investigation.

Could Evolution face legal costs if CK's UPEPA application succeeds?
Yes. Depending on the court's findings and the applicable statutory requirements, a successful UPEPA application could expose Evolution to an award of legal fees and related expenses.

Would a settlement with CK end Evolution's lawsuit against Black Cube?
No. A separate agreement involving Calcagni & Kanefsky would not automatically resolve Evolution's claims against Black Cube or other defendants.

What role does Playtech have in Evolution's legal dispute?
Evolution has sought to bring Playtech into the litigation over its alleged involvement in commissioning the Black Cube investigation. Playtech's potential involvement remains a separate legal issue.

What happens next in the Evolution and Black Cube lawsuit?
Black Cube's UPEPA arguments were scheduled for 17 November 2026 before Judge John C. Porto. The status of CK's separate hearing remained unclear when the article was written.

Share

Michael Schmitt is the founder of TRIDER.UK and Editor of Malta Media. He writes about iGaming, gambling regulation, corporate structures, financial services and market integrity, combining investigative journalism with nearly three decades of experience in corporate services and international business.